shimotsuki: kaleidoscope.jpg (kaleidoscope)
[personal profile] shimotsuki
I haven't had as much fic-writing time as I would have liked, lately, but working on this one in tiny little pieces has at least been a stress-reliever!

As always, I intend this as a stand-alone story within the Kaleidoscope series, but it's also part of the same story arc as Breaking Point and Messages -- what I'm thinking of as the "in-laws sequence," heh.


Porridge (2638 words | PG)
Andromeda finds that the loss of her husband and the imminent arrival of her grandson have changed the way she views her son-in-law. But she has built her share of the walls between them, and it may be too late for her to pull them down.

Porridge

A soft knock on the half-open study door made Andromeda start and look up.

Her son-in-law hovered in the doorway, poised to knock again, but when she raised her eyebrows in invitation, he lowered his hand and offered a hesitant smile instead.

"I was wondering if I might speak with you for a moment."

"Of course." She traced out an arc with her wand that sent a stack of musty dragonhide ledgers from the wing chair to a safe spot underneath her writing desk. "Do come in and sit down."

Remus stepped gingerly around the piles of parchment on the floor. They were growing taller every day—Andromeda had gone up to the attic and pulled out all the letters and documents she could find that pertained to the Black family, and now she was combing through them page by page in search of any information that might possibly be of some vague use to the Order of the Phoenix.

She should have started this project three years ago, of course. But once upon a time, she had wanted to keep herself, and her family, safely away from Dumbledore and his penchant for stirring up trouble.

This year, trouble had found her. And her daughter's little family-to-be. And Ted—

Andromeda blinked, hard, and blocked that train of thought, watching Remus lower himself stiffly into the wing chair. He didn't look well at all; there was a decidedly grey cast to his complexion, and the fine lines around his eyes and mouth were especially pronounced today. She was more or less used to his patterns by now, but his rather haggard appearance right before the full moon was still a little disconcerting.

Remus smiled again, a swift, careful smile. His manner was friendly, as always, but his eyes were guarded.

As always.

It was only fair, she supposed, for him to return suspicion with suspicion. She hadn't exactly been warm toward him at first—this man who started out so afraid to be a husband, and then a father, that he had broken Nymphadora's heart twice.

"Was there something in particular you wanted to talk about?" Andromeda was honestly rather curious. The two of them had settled into something of an uneasy truce this spring, but Remus rarely sought her out for idle conversation.

He sighed a little, not quite meeting her gaze. "There's a full moon tonight."

"Yes." A lunar chart had been hung in a convenient spot in the kitchen, after all, so that everyone in the house could keep track of these things. "I know."

Remus nodded, but it took him a moment to begin speaking again.

"Has Nymphadora told you that she's been having contractions from time to time?"

"No." Andromeda frowned, counting days. According to Poppy Pomfrey, the baby wasn't due for another two weeks.

"They aren't very frequent," said Remus quickly. "It's only been a few times a day. But if anything were to happen tonight—" He pressed his lips together. "I would like to ask a favour."

Andromeda managed to hide a wry smile. If she had learnt anything about her son-in-law over the last eight months, it was that he hated asking for favours nearly as much as he was mortified by having to discuss his lycanthropy. This was not, it seemed, his lucky day.

"I'll be here tonight," she assured him. "I won't leave Nymphadora alone."

Remus nodded. "Thank you. But—"

His mask had slipped; now he was looking at her with an almost desperate intensity that was very different from the careful politeness she usually saw.

She was curious again.

He tried to smile. "It's not only that. It's—I'd give anything to know, if our son—"

His throat seemed to close up over those words. But it clearly wasn't panic, not this time.

"—if anything happens."

Remus pulled a little plastic Muggle mirror out of his pocket, one of the many two-way mirrors he'd Charmed for the Order, and held it out to her. "Would you let me know?"

Andromeda stared at the thing.

She couldn't raise her hand to take it from him.

He flushed. "You won't have to see anything. I'll keep out of the line of sight while I'm transformed. But if you could just speak into the mirror, and tell me if anything happens, and how Dora's doing..."

Speak into the mirror.

Andromeda felt herself blanch.

"Oh," Remus whispered, suddenly understanding. "Oh, Merlin. Andromeda, I'm sorry."

She hadn't used one of these mirrors since the night that Ted had told her he was in a tight spot, that he might not have a chance to contact her again for a few hours—

Since the last time she had spoken to her husband alive.

Anguished compassion displaced the careful reserve in her son-in-law's eyes, and Andromeda could not—could not—look at it. She focused on the mirror instead, clutched in the white-knuckled grip of a hand that was already showing traces of a pre-moon tremor.

This mirror was green. It wasn't like the blue pair she and Ted had used.

Andromeda took a deep breath.

Remus was asking this favour of her because his concern for Nymphadora, and the weight of his impending fatherhood, were enough to make him set aside his stiff, prickly pride and admit that he needed help.

And it was, after all, Remus who had given them their mirrors in the first place. The last few months of Ted's life would have been far lonelier for both of them without that.

She reached out and closed her fingers around the little green trinket, nodding slowly.

"It's all right," she said, around the ache in her throat. "I'll do it. If anything happens, I will tell you right away."

"Thank you."

His smile was still swift, but it wasn't quite as guarded this time.

. * . * .

"Oh, don't get up yet!" Nymphadora's voice sounded from the living room, breaking the drowsy silence that had settled over the little house. "You still have a few minutes."

Andromeda rubbed the back of her neck and stretched her shoulders. If Remus was getting ready to leave, two more hours must have slipped past since their little talk. Not that she minded; every time she lost herself poring over old property records, it kept her from thinking about—anything else.

She crossed the study to the doorway that opened onto the living room.

Remus was, indeed, sitting upright on the sofa. Nymphadora could usually coax him into lying down with his head in her lap (or on her knee, now that she didn't have much lap to speak of) for the last hour or so before he had to leave for the transformation. This little ritual seemed to be the only thing that stopped his restless pacing as moonrise neared—not even his obvious exhaustion kept him still, but Nymphadora's fingers gently stroking the greying hair could do it.

Now, he seemed to be gathering his waning strength to stand, until suddenly he leaned toward Nymphadora again. He said something in a low voice and brushed his thumb along the line of her jaw, and there was a bright, eager light in his eyes that put a smile of pure joy on Nymphadora's face.

Only, Andromeda knew with utter certainty that if she stepped out into the living room, that light would go out faster than a wordless Nox. Such a soul-baring look of love was not something a careful man would show.

A wave of weary anger washed over her, and she thumped a fist softly against the doorjamb. It was so stupid, the way they danced around each other, always so cautious and polite. Especially in times like these.

And she was the one who had laid the first bricks in the wall that loomed between them.

"No! I'm not going to promise you that!" The vehemence in Nymphadora's voice caught Andromeda's attention.

She peered around the door again to see her daughter scowling up at Remus, who now stood (swaying slightly) with his arms crossed and his jaw set very firmly.

"Andromeda?" he called. She stepped out into the living room, and he turned to her for the second time that day with a look of appeal. "You agree, don't you? Nymphadora should most certainly not be on her feet tonight just to make porridge for my breakfast. I can fix myself some toast and jam when I come back in the morning. Or fry an egg."

Nymphadora's face was stormy, and she opened her mouth to argue, but Andromeda spoke first. "Remus is absolutely right, love. Especially if you've been having contractions?"

She raised an eyebrow, pointedly, and her daughter had the grace to look sheepish through her scowl.

"Sorry, Mum," Nymphadora muttered. "I didn't think it was worth getting everyone all fussed about that yet."

"Dora." Remus settled himself on the sofa once more and caught her hands in his, looking straight into her eyes. "I'll be worrying all night if I think you're overdoing things. Please—no porridge."

Nymphadora stared back, unconvinced.

"I'll be fine." He gave her a wry smile. "I managed for years on my own. You know that."

The clock on the mantel chimed the quarter hour, and he glanced at it distractedly. "I'd better go." He leaned in for a gentle kiss. "Promise me?"

Nymphadora sighed. "All right," she said, rather crossly. "No porridge."

Remus stood, and Nymphadora looked up at him, contrite now. "Take care of yourself," she whispered. "I'll see you in the morning."

Taking a firm grip on the battered leather coin purse that was one of the Weasley twins' Confundus Portkeys, Remus wished them good night. Then he touched the Portkey with his wand and vanished.

Nymphadora crumpled, burying her face in her hands. "It's not fair. He shouldn't have made me promise."

Andromeda perched beside her daughter on the sofa and put an arm around her shoulders. It wasn't like Nymphadora to be this petulant, but surely she was drowning in hormones.

And neither of them had really been themselves, this last month.

"He really will be all right fending for himself in the morning, you know," she said softly.

"I know." Nymphadora raised a tear-stained face. "But fixing porridge is the only thing I can do to make a difference for him." She closed her eyes. "For anyone."

Andromeda pulled her daughter into the tightest hug she could manage around a bellyful of grandson. It was too late to make a difference for some people.

But maybe not for everyone.

. * . * .

The house was dark and silent, except for a single pool of lamplight where Andromeda sat at her dressing table. She had cleaned her teeth and brushed her hair; now she was ready for bed.

Except for one thing.

She looked down to see her own face, staring mutely up at her from the little green mirror.

Her gaze slid past the mirror and found a framed photo of Ted, waving cheerfully at the camera with that great broad smile that always used to mean, Things will be fine, Dromeda, you'll see.

Remus had asked for this. It was the first time he had ever freely asked her for anything.

Pressing her lips together, she raised her wand and tapped it firmly against the mirror's plastic frame.

Her reflection wavered and disappeared. A bleak stone wall came into view, with what looked like the corner of a bed in the foreground, as though the other mirror were propped up against a pillow. The room in the mirror was dim, lit only by flickering firelight.

"Remus?" Andromeda frowned. "I hope you can hear me."

Silence.

She cleared her throat. "I only wanted to let you know that Nymphadora is fine. She's gone to bed, in fact. I don't think anything is going to happen tonight."

Silence again. Nothing moved in the mirror but the shadows from the firelight.

Andromeda sighed. "If you can hear me, could you let me know, please? I'd like to be certain you've received the news."

Still nothing, for a moment. But then came the faintest of yips.

She smiled, in spite of herself, suddenly reminded of an Alsatian she'd been fond of as a girl. "That's all right, then. I'll let you know if anything changes."

She picked up her wand to tap the mirror again, in order to clear it. But then she hesitated.

"Try to get some rest tonight, Remus. We'll see you in the morning."

. * . * .

Andromeda had spelled her wand to chime at moonset and wake her up—partly so that she could send Nymphadora back to bed, if necessary. But when she peeked in through her daughter's bedroom door, which had been left ajar, she saw that Nymphadora was, mercifully, asleep.

She pulled the door closed and padded downstairs to the kitchen.

She had only just finished fixing herself a cup of tea when Remus appeared, clutching his Portkey. He was off balance when his feet first touched the floor, but he quickly caught the edge of the counter and managed to keep himself upright.

Andromeda swallowed. This was the first time she had seen her son-in-law immediately after his transformation. He looked grey and shaky, and there were dark rings under his eyes.

Those eyes burned, though, when he turned to her. "Is Dora all right?"

"She's fine—she's still asleep." Andromeda frowned. "Sit down, Remus. You look like you're about to fall over."

He limped the few steps to the table and dropped into a chair, breathing rather heavily. "Thank you for letting me know, last night." Even his voice was painfully hoarse.

"That's quite all right." Andromeda turned to the cauldron that sat on the cooker under a Warming Charm and ladled out a bowl of porridge. She set it at Remus's place, along with a pitcher of cream, and sat down at the table across from him.

Remus stared at the bowl, and then up at Andromeda again. "But Nymphadora promised."

Andromeda watched him steadily, noting his dismay and concern, so close to the surface now. Maybe his exhaustion made it harder for him to keep the mask in place.

She sipped at her tea. "Do you know the story behind the porridge?"

Remus blinked once. "Well, Dora did tell me she learned the recipe from her father."

"That's right," said Andromeda, lost for a moment in the memory of a young Ted, laughing as a small girl with pink pigtails added enough cinnamon to turn the porridge brown.

She closed her eyes firmly and opened them again to a silent kitchen, dim in the early-morning light, and a pair of weary eyes that were fixed intently on hers.

"Ted's mother would make it for him when he was ill, or had a football match or an examination. Nymphadora always loved it, too. Ted would fix it whenever she was feeling tired or sad, or on the days when she was leaving to go back to Hogwarts."

"So it's the family comfort food," said Remus softly. A faint flush coloured his cheeks. "That's why Nymphadora is always so insistent about making it for me after moons." But then he frowned. "I still wish she hadn't made it this time, though. She needs her rest."

"It's all right," said Andromeda. "Nymphadora didn't make the porridge this time."

Remus sat very still for the space of a few heartbeats. She smiled a little at the look of puzzlement on his face.

But then a smile of his own appeared—not the swift, furtive one he usually gave her, but a slow, warm smile that lit up his eyes from within.

"Thank you, Andromeda."

She reached across the table and touched his arm briefly. "You're welcome."

Andromeda thought she could trust him to catch all of the meanings she'd put into those words.

. * fin * .



Author's note: The question of timing that drives the plot of this story has a certain similarity with that in [livejournal.com profile] godricgal's lovely pre-DH story All That's Required. But—believe it or not—I've had the germ of this idea in the back of my mind since before I read hers, so I hope no one minds that I've played around with a similar premise. (And yes, that does mean that I'm slooooow at getting things written!)

"Kaleidoscope" series index

.

Date: 2009-05-24 09:40 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] hrymfaxe.livejournal.com
Oh yay!! :D:D I like it a lot! I'll leave a proper comment tomorrow, because I'm very much in need of going to bed now so I can be refreshed for work... Stupid RL!

PS: I'm glad you have had time to relax with some fic-writing.

Date: 2009-05-25 02:13 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] train-lindz.livejournal.com
This is absolutely lovely :)

The acceptance and cautious relationship between Remus and Andromeda is worderful.

I love this series.

Date: 2009-05-25 05:34 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] sspring92.livejournal.com
Thank you! It has kind of been a crappy Sunday for too many reasons to go into here. This was a lovely surprise on my friends page! The idea of Tonks being so upset that she couldn't make her father's "Comfort food" for Remus was so touching and a bit heartbreaking! I often wondered in Andromeda would ever accept Remus, sounds like this was the start of that!

Date: 2009-05-25 01:33 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
Aw, thanks -- but don't feel you have to worry about "proper comments," lol, I'm just happy to hear you liked this. :)

Date: 2009-05-25 01:34 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
Aw, thank you! I'm glad you like the way the relationship between these two is developing. :)

Date: 2009-05-25 01:36 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
I'm so sorry you had a crappy Sunday. :( But thanks so much for the kind words. This was a little hard to write without getting too emotional about it all, but it is after all a kind of emotional time for all these folks... And yeah, I think Andromeda would really appreciate Remus once she decided to give him a chance (and vice versa).

Date: 2009-05-25 01:57 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] mrstater.livejournal.com
Oh, this is lovely. I can't think of a more fitting way for your Andromeda and Remus to finally get beyond their tense, careful relationship than through this situation of Remus being forced to ask for help and Andromeda realizing that it's time to get beyond herself and respond. The way Tonks is the catalyst for this, while keeping a relatively low profile in the story, is beautifully handled. She doesn't realize just how much she does do for people.

Also, having Andromeda finally see Remus in an unrestrained moment is really perfect after all the times in your stories she's been frustrated by him. (Pot, kettle, black much, Andi? ;))

Very well done! Thanks for a lovely start to Memorial Day.
Edited Date: 2009-05-25 01:58 pm (UTC)

Date: 2009-05-25 05:11 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
Thank you so much for the encouraging comments. I really wrestled with how to write Andromeda here without getting ridiculously emo (many were the drafts, especially of scene two). But I wanted to work with the idea that losing her husband would make her more inclined to reach out to what's left of her family, and help all the positive things she's observed about Remus over the last several months finally sink in. ...Only now I'm afraid that by cutting out some of the emo-ness, I've lost that connection to Ted's death as a kind of turning point, heh. Maybe I need to rethink this (again!) for the eventual rewrite. ;P

Anyway, I'm happy to hear that this was a fun read.

Date: 2009-05-26 01:33 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] gilpin25.livejournal.com
Am here to swap Andromeda compliments. ;)

I saved this as a treat for when the bank holiday was over, and of course, it was. To misquote the famous carol, your Andromeda is such a perfect mix of crisp, even and deep. It's easy to imagine her exactly as described in DH: looking a little haughty and yet with kind eyes. It's also easy to see why she's such hard work for Remus, though - Andromeda isn't a Molly or any of the people we see in the books so openly emotional and needing the comfort that Remus knows just how to give. It's fitting that it takes an unexpected moment of deep vulnerablity in them both, and them recognising it as such in the other, that makes a hole in the wall of reserve and misunderstanding between them.

I read your comment to [livejournal.com profile] mrstater about losing some of the emo-ness, but I felt as if there was a great deal, it's just nicely understated and it feels just right. Not looking at Remus when Andromeda sees his compassion for her seems exactly how he reacts to displays of feeling for him when the roles are reversed, and Tonks is such a contrast in her openness and mind-speaking to them both (which always makes me think she's the perfect counter to and for Remus).

I loved the part about Remus reassuring Andromeda that she wouldn't have to see him as a wolf, his careful placement of the mirror to ensure that, and the little yip - you can almost feel him weighing up his possible options with the last before deciding to go for it, and the affectionate moment when Andromeda is reminded of the Alsation. That's reinforced when she sees him for the first time directly after the transformation and it brings home to her what he suffers and also what he conceals.

And the ending makes me want to cheer a little. The porridge Remus could put down simply to a considerate act, standing in for her daughter, but she talks to him about Ted. She opens up to let him respond in kind and it's comfort food for them both.

Thank you for such a lovely lunchtime read. Here's to the next in this series. ♥

Date: 2009-05-26 05:23 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] mrstater.livejournal.com
Only now I'm afraid that by cutting out some of the emo-ness, I've lost that connection to Ted's death as a kind of turning point, heh.

Oh no, I don't think you've lost that at all. I think it was very clear throughout (especially with the whole thing with the mirrors and her initial reluctance to let someone else in to what she'd shared with Ted, both in the communication it brought them while he was on the run as well as that tragedy at the last) that Andromeda was turning to her family (and inviting Remus into that familial fold) because she no longer has Ted as her comfort zone to withdraw into. So no worries!

Date: 2009-05-26 09:02 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
(*snort* At first I misread that and thought you meant of course the Bank Holiday was over. ;) )

I really appreciate your reassurance! For some reason this one never quite felt like it gelled, but I'm glad you thought Andromeda's actions and responses made sense here. I'm also relieved to hear the emotional aspects were evident without being too much; I kind of felt like I was writing this with a thick trowelful of emo, and had to scrape it off ruthlessly in the editing phase, lol.

I like your insight that Andromeda would be harder for Remus to relate to if she didn't (seem like she) needed anything from him...

Thanks again for the kind comments. I will push on!

Date: 2009-05-26 09:04 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
Thanks for the reassurance! I edited and changed this one so much it got to be hard to think about how what was left on the page would read on its own, lol.

Date: 2009-05-26 10:20 pm (UTC)
From: (Anonymous)
Aw, this was lovely. I'm glad to see Andromeda warming up to Remus more, here.

Will you be writing a fic where Tonks actually gives birth to Teddy, I'd like to see you take on that.

Anyway, this made my day and I'm so glad I got to read it. =)

Date: 2009-05-27 01:25 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] tegdoh.livejournal.com
You write Andromeda so well - just as I pictured her, with her Black aloofness masking an underlying compassion. And of course Remus' own reserve would make it that much harder for the two of them to develop any kind of close relationship.

I love how you've underscored the angst of Andromeda losing Ted with her determination to help the Order, which culminates very naturally into her wanting to make a difference for Remus, as well.

I think this is my favorite part

A wave of weary anger washed over her, and she thumped a fist softly against the doorjamb. It was so stupid, the way they danced around each other, always so cautious and polite. Especially in times like these.

because her anger and frustration seem very real.

Lovely.

Date: 2009-05-27 03:03 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
Thanks so much. I'm becoming quite fond of Andromeda. :)

I will definitely be writing a fic about Teddy's birth, but I'm not sure exactly when -- I work on different parts of the R/T timeline as inspiration strikes, and I have some ideas about OotP and HBP as well as DH... not sure which one will happen next!

Date: 2009-05-27 03:06 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
I really like your Andromeda, so I'm very happy to hear you think mine works too. :)

You've hit on some of the things I wanted to do here -- like showing how Ted's death has shaken Andromeda out of her complacency (~denial?) about both the war and her daughter's marriage. And I'm especially glad to hear you liked the "weary anger" paragraph, because that replaced a torrent of angsty internal-monologuing in the first draft, heh.

Date: 2009-05-27 07:27 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] gilpin25.livejournal.com
(*snort* At first I misread that and thought you meant of course the Bank Holiday was over. ;) )

*snorts back* Am not sure it was my most eloquent sentence ever: remind me not to use it in something original any time soon!

Date: 2009-05-27 08:16 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] carnivalgirl.livejournal.com
I read the sneak-peek of this on metamorfic_moon, and I really enjoyed the rest of it! I think it was engaging and had just the right level of emotional stuff and plot. The porridge bit was my absolute favourite, especially as it was Andromeda that made it for him. Her talking to him was also very poignant, it was a really nice, understated way to show her change in attitude. The moments of Remus/Tonks were very sweet as well.

Date: 2009-05-28 02:47 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
Thanks so much for coming by to read the rest of the story! I appreciate the feedback, especially on the balance of character/emotional development and plot.

Date: 2009-05-30 10:48 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] solochan.livejournal.com
I love this, your characterisation of the characters are so heart felt and touching, and how you really see Tonks/Remus from a distance - and yet also see their...polite way of living. I love the idea of a baby Ted too, I need to read more Ted/Andy stuff at some point...

Loved this, want to read more ^^

Date: 2009-05-30 01:43 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] solochan.livejournal.com
I've just spent a good 2 hours reading the whole of the series, and what can I say? It's beautifully written, and constructed beautifully, your portrayal of the characters are amazingly done, and your Remus makes me feel all...good inside, he's not emo-y and the way that he has to re-earn Dora's love is again fantastic. I'm really looking forward to leading up to Teddy's birthday and how you deal with Ted's death (I love Ted so hard, and how you write him is just as amazing)

Keep up the good work, i'll be looking forward to reading the rest ^^

Date: 2009-05-30 07:06 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
Wow, I'm really happy to hear that reading this story got you reading the rest of the series! :) Thanks so much for the encouragement, and especially the kind comments about characterization, which is something I try to work on.

Date: 2009-09-27 03:10 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] paulamcg.livejournal.com
I’ve been happy to continue reading about your Remus and Andromeda here – and I’m ready to give a chance to the Tonks-pov story, too. I can’t help it: it pleases me to hear that you concluded you and your characters had better stop using Patronus messages. And now I’d like to go on and complain that being able to Apparate immediately before and after the transformation (as well as the chance to use Wolfsbane Potion, unless it has some side effects) can make things too easy for Remus. In any case your Remus suffers evocatively enough – at least in Tonks's view – here. And perhaps in a way it’s harder for him when he keeps his conscious mind in his wolf form.

And to the point of the story: porridge. It definitely didn’t disappoint me. It’s wonderful how you reveal its importance – the story behind the porridge: the current story behind this portion as well as the backstory – only towards the end. So lovely to see Remus’s true smile. Above all, I enjoy seeing how Andromeda ends up simply helping him without too much talk about it – and how you’ve made this a full, important story about her by including her loss of Ted – while those two in love are so inordinately and loudly worried about each other. Finally (or was it first of all) I love the way your Remus finds it hard to ask for help.

Date: 2009-10-01 04:06 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ladymirth.livejournal.com
This is a very beautiful piece that captures perfectly the undercurrents of love, dissension and grief behind simple words and homely rituals in domesticity. I feel like I'd just seen a painting in muted colors that moved me very much. It's stories like this that stay with you.

Date: 2009-10-01 06:15 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
Thank you for your supportive feedback! I'm especially glad to hear that you liked this view of Andromeda, and her understated way of trying to reconcile with Remus, as well as the characterization of Remus presented here.

being able to Apparate immediately before and after the transformation (as well as the chance to use Wolfsbane Potion, unless it has some side effects) can make things too easy for Remus

Ah, but I agree with you about the Apparition -- in the world of my fic series, Apparating is quite dangerous for Remus in his weakened state after the full moon, so he only risks it in an emergency (I actually used that as a minor plot point in an early story, "Reaction"). In this story, he's using a Weasley-developed untraceable Portkey, which is a convenience I'm allowing the Order to have in DH.

As for the Wolfsbane, we may have to agree to disagree on that one! Part of my overall story arc, which I think might be quite different from how you see Remus's story, is that he gradually becomes less isolated and more emotionally open, as well as more materially comfortable, as he builds himself a family through the course of DH (*coughs* and on into my self-indulgent postwar AU world). So I've decided that Remus has no regular access to Wolfsbane during GoF, OotP, or HBP. But after he reconciles with Tonks, she convinces him to let her brew it for him. (The Weasley twins take over once she is expecting and shouldn't be brewing with aconite.)

As I've said before, though, I really enjoy reading well-thought-out takes on Remus and rest of the HP world that differ from my own -- the differences make things interesting. :)

(Also, I wanted to let you know that I've had very limited LJ time for the last couple of weeks, but this coming weekend I hope to have some time to read more of "Revolt.")

Date: 2009-10-01 06:17 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
a painting in muted colors that moved me very much

That's such a beautiful compliment! Thank you so much for reading, and for your kind words.

Date: 2009-10-04 08:09 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] paulamcg.livejournal.com
Thank you for pointing me to this reply, which I had missed due to the disappearance of my email account.

And first of all, let me apologise: I’ve been careless. I wrote my comment several days after reading the story, and by that time I had forgotten that your Remus used a Portkey. This means of transportation, too, can make things too easy for characters, but the Portkey serves the story well here. I’m glad to realise your Remus didn’t Apparate here, particularly when it means that you can use and have used the risks in Apparition as a plot point elsewhere – not that we’d need to agree about the risks.

Your take on Wolfsbane Potion’s role in Remus’s story certainly sounds well-thought-out and interestingly different from mine. When you’ve made the potion clearly beneficial, but risky for the brewer (if I understood correctly), it can serve you well in the kind of story you want to tell about Remus’s evolving personal relationships.

(And thank you. I’ll be looking forward to more feedback, while trying to polish the next chapter further.)

Date: 2014-05-28 04:27 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] anne foley (from livejournal.com)
oh god i'm crying god bless. This is utter perfection and I love you.

Date: 2014-06-11 03:39 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] shimotsuki.livejournal.com
Aw! Thanks for the kind comment, and I'm glad you enjoyed this!

December 2017

S M T W T F S
     12
3456789
101112131415 16
17181920212223
24252627282930
31      

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated March 30th, 2026 08:58 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios